Mystery rocket crash site found on moon

There is a rocky urface, an arrow points at a crater.
A rocket body struck the moon on March 4, 2022, near Hertzsprung crater. It created a double crater roughly 100 feet (28 meters) wide in its longest dimension. Image via NASA/ Goddard/ Arizona State University.

Late in 2021, astronomers spotted what turned out to be a spent rocket body hurtling toward Earth’s moon. And now NASA’s Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter – which has been photographing the moon since 2009 – has seen the rocket’s crash site. But the origin of this rocket is still a mystery. Which rocket was it? Also, when the rocket hit, it left an interesting double crater. And the crater is mysterious, too. Why is it double? As it turns out, the strange double crater – site of the crash itself – might help to identify which rocket it was that crashed.

The Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter team described the situation this way in a June 24, 2022, press release:

Impact occurred March 4, 2022, with NASA’s Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter later spotting the resulting crater. Surprisingly the crater is actually two craters, an eastern crater (18-meter diameter, about 19.5 yards) superimposed on a western crater (16-meter diameter, about 17.5 yards).

Planetary geologist Mark Robinson of Arizona State University – who serves as the principal investigator for the camera aboard NASA’s Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter – told the New York Times:

It’s cool, because it’s an unexpected outcome. That’s always way more fun than if the prediction of the crater, its depth and diameter, had been exactly right.

Weird crater could help solve the mystery

That double-crater impact could be the key to identifying the mystery rocket. NASA says the unusual formation could only come from an impactor of a certain shape:

The double crater was unexpected and may indicate that the rocket body had large masses at each end. Typically a spent rocket has mass concentrated at the motor end; the rest of the rocket stage mainly consists of an empty fuel tank. Since the origin of the rocket body remains uncertain, the double nature of the crater may indicate its identity.

By comparison, NASA says previous rocket body impact on the lunar surface look nothing like the new, enigmatic scarring:

No other rocket body impacts on the moon created double craters. The four Apollo SIV-B craters were somewhat irregular in outline (Apollos 13, 14, 15, 17) and were substantially larger (greater than 35 meters, about 38 yards) than each of the double craters. The maximum width (29 meters, about 31.7 yards) of the double crater of the mystery rocket body was near that of the S-IVBs.

Rocky surface with an object hitting it and creating a hole.
These 4 images show craters formed by impacts of the Apollo SIV-B stages: crater diameters range from 35 to 40 meters (38.2 to 43.7 yards) in the longest dimension. Image via: NASA/ Goddard/ Arizona State University.

Whose rocket is this?

Bill Gray, an amateur astronomer who took the lead in trying to unmask the owners of the errant rocket body, at first thought it must be a SpaceX vehicle, but eventually decided it must be part of a Chinese launch, a booster from the Chang’e 5-T1 lunar mission, which launched in 2014. The rocket body was discovered – and originally misidentified – in 2015.

But, despite data that confirmed the ID, Gray says the Chinese government denied ownership, and it’s his opinion they’ve made an honest mistake, confusing Chang’e 5-T1 and the similarly named Chang’e 5:

I think the Ministry of Foreign Affairs simply got two different, but similarly named, lunar missions mixed up.

I should note that many have gotten these two missions mixed up before at one time or another. (Picture my hand raised here.) Given that, I think this was probably an honest error on the part of the Foreign Ministry.

Further, Gray says he’s convinced from his analysis the rocket body was part of Chang’e 5-T1:

In a sense, all this remains “circumstantial” evidence. But I would regard it as fairly convincing evidence, the sort where the jury would file out of the courtroom and come back in a few minutes with a conviction.

Rocky surface with 2 craters in the center.
This animated GIF confirms the location of the newly formed rocket body double crater. The before image is LRO’s view from Feb. 28, 2022. The after image is from May 21, 2022. The width of the frame is 367 meters, about 401 yards. Image via: NASA/ Goddard/ Arizona State University.

China says its rocket burned in orbit

According to a report from, the Chinese believe the Chang’e 5-T1 booster Gray thinks is the lunar impactor burned up in the atmosphere:

“According to China’s monitoring, the upper stage of the rocket related to the Chang’e-5 mission entered into Earth’s atmosphere and completely burned up,” Foreign Ministry spokesperson Wang Wenbin said February 21, 2022.

However, this may be the misidentification Gray pointed out, as the mission named by the ministry’s spokesperson in’s article is the wrong one.

According to reporting by The Verge, the US Space Force confirmed Chang’e 5-T1 did not burn in Earth’s atmosphere:

Some other confusion revolved around the fact that the Space Force’s 18th Space Control Squadron (18SPCS) — which keeps track of space debris around Earth — noted on its tracking website that the rocket from the Chang’e 5-T1 mission returned to our planet about a year after launch and burned up in our atmosphere. However, the 18SPCS later confirmed in a statement to The Verge that the Long March 3C from the flight did not actually reenter our atmosphere and has been in space ever since its launch.

Bottom line: A mystery rocket body has struck the lunar surface leaving an unusual crater, and where the rocket body came from is uncertain.

June 30, 2022

Like what you read?
Subscribe and receive daily news delivered to your inbox.

Your email address will only be used for EarthSky content. Privacy Policy
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

More from 

Dave Adalian

View All