Why super-sized beavers went extinct

Super-sized beavers were as big as black bears. They suddenly became extinct 10,000 years ago, while small modern beavers survived. Now scientists know why.

Purple silhouettes of a modern beaver, a standing man, and a giant beaver.

A side-by-side comparison of a modern beaver, a human male (in this case, Justin Bieber) and a giant bear-sized beaver from 10,000 years ago. Illustration by Scott Woods/Western University.

By Tessa Plint, Western University

Giant beavers the size of black bears once roamed the lakes and wetlands of North America. Fortunately for cottage-goers, these mega-rodents died out at the end of the last ice age.

Now extinct, the giant beaver was once a highly successful species. Scientists have found its fossil remains at sites from Florida to Alaska and the Yukon.

A super-sized version of the modern beaver in appearance, the giant beaver tipped the scales at 100 kilograms [220 pounds]. But it had two crucial differences.

The giant beaver lacked the iconic paddle-shaped tail we see on today’s modern beavers. Instead it had a long skinny tail like a muskrat.

The teeth also looked different. Modern beaver incisors (front teeth) are sharp and chisel-like; giant beaver incisors were bulkier and curved, and lacked a sharp cutting edge.

A brown skull with 2 large round tusk-like teeth on the top and bottom.

Giant beaver skull. Image via Florida Museum of Natural History.

The species suddenly became extinct 10,000 years ago. The disappearance of the giant beaver coincides with that of many other large-bodied ice age animals, including the iconic woolly mammoth. But until now scientists didn’t know for certain why the giant rodent had died out.

You are what you eat

We need to understand how the giant beaver lived in order to explain how and why it died out. For example, did it run out of food? Did it get too cold or too hot for it to survive?

Other studies found the giant beaver thrived when the climate was warmer and wetter. They also noticed that giant beaver fossils were most commonly found in sediments that come from ancient wetlands. But no one knew if the giant beaver behaved like the modern beaver. Did it also cut down trees? Or did it eat something completely different?

From a chemical perspective, you are what you eat! The food an animal consumes contains chemical signatures called stable isotopes that are incorporated into body tissues such as bone.

These isotopic signatures remain stable over time, for tens of thousands of years, and provide a window into the past. No other studies have used stable isotopes to figure out the giant beaver’s diet.

Drawing of big beaver at the edge of the water, and another beaver swimming.

The now-extinct giant beaver once lived from Florida to Alaska. It weighed as much as 220 pounds (100 kilograms), roughly the same as a small black bear. Illustration via Luke Dickey/Western University.

We studied fossil bones from giant beavers that lived in the Yukon and Ohio between 50,000 and 10,000 years ago. We looked at the stable isotope signatures of the ancient bone tissues.

The isotopic signatures linked to woody plants are different from those associated with aquatic plants. We discovered that the giant beaver was not cutting down and eating trees. Instead, it was eating aquatic plants.

This strongly suggests that the giant beaver was not an “ecosystem engineer” like the modern beaver. It was not cutting down trees for food or building giant lodges and dams across the ice age landscape.

Instead, this diet of aquatic plants made the giant beaver highly dependent on wetland habitat for both food and shelter from predators. It also made it vulnerable to climate change.

Warm and dry climate

Towards the end of the last ice age 10,000 years ago, the climate became increasingly warm and dry and wetland habitats began to dry up. Although the modern beavers and the giant beaver co-existed on the landscape for tens of thousands of years, only one species survived.

The ability to build dams and lodges may have given the modern beaver a competitive advantage over the giant beaver. With its sharp teeth, the modern beaver could alter the landscape to create suitable wetland habitat where it needed it. The giant beaver couldn’t.

Animal skeleton with big teeth on a white background.

A giant beaver skeleton. Image via Tessa Plint.

This all fits into the puzzle that many research groups have been working on for decades: we all want to know what caused the global megafauna extinction event that occurred at the end of the last ice age and why so many species of large-bodied animals — woolly mammoths, mastodons and giant ground sloths — disappeared at roughly the same time.

Current evidence indicates that a combination of climate change and human impact were the driving causes behind these extinctions.

Studying the ecological vulnerabilities of long-extinct animals certainly poses its own unique challenges, but it is important to understand the impact of climate change on all species, past or present.

Tessa Plint, Ph.D. researcher, Heriot-Watt University, and former graduate student, Western University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Bottom line: Human-sized beavers in North America suddenly became extinct at the end of the last ice age 10,000 years ago, while small modern beavers survived. By studying fossils, scientists have discovered that giant beavers ate aquatic plants instead of trees, leaving the species vulnerable to climate change.

The Conversation

EarthSky Voices

MORE ARTICLES